The 5 Most Common Mistakes Bloggers Make

Great blogs are based on great content–good design, creative network capability, and, especially, great writing. When bloggers get it right, it can be a beautiful thing. At the moment when an audience connects with great online writers and content curators, a blog becomes a space for transformational experiences. This is a dynamic place, living and moving and changing as the limits on the imagination disappear in the grand depths of internet space. A quarter of the web is blog content, a massive intercontinental viral library where amateurs and experts alike are drawn into the ever-expansive possibilities of the digital age.

This is a space that you can–and should–be a part of. Whether you are building a digital platform, testing material for new markets, or using the blog as a sandbox for writing or design, this space is ideal for finding an audience. Even when bloggers have the key elements for success–regular posting, relevance, strong writing, readable design, and a meaningful connection to readers–there can be a gap between the blogger and his or her audience. Many bloggers are creating great content but finding that their blog is getting little traction. When no one is reading, the blogosphere can be a lonely place.

Time and time again I see good writers making the same critical errors that keep the blog from experiencing long-term growth. These errors–often simple ones–keep their content from being as sticky as it could be and gets in the way of the blogger’s ability to capitalize on the viral nature of online writing. If you are creating great content, you want to make meaningful connections to a readership.

So I thought I would share the top 5 mistakes that bloggers make that limit their reach. These are the lessons I’ve learned on my way to becoming a specialized blog that still gets 100,000 hits a year.

Blogger Mistake #1: They Don’t Use WordPress

I know, I know: there are a lot of loyal Blogspot/Blogger writers out there. There are critical disadvantages to WordPress, including the fact that it takes a bit of digital know-how to take your first steps as a baby blogger. A little patience with WordPress, however, goes a long way. Besides data–which is essential for the blogger interested in impact–there are three critical reasons that bloggers interested in digital impact should consider WordPress.

First, WordPress is pretty. Or at least it can be. There are thousands of design templates that allows each WordPress site to stand out. We are a visual generation, and WordPress facilitates the use of pictures and design features that enhance our content.

Second, WordPress has a greater potential for connecting with other bloggers. This is not just a matter of sheer mass. Statistics vary, but there are more than 60 million WordPress users, making it the most powerful content management system (CMS) on the web. The potential for connectivity actually has more to do with ease than mass. I can follow WordPress blogs by email or in a reader, allowing me to make a far bigger digital net than I can anywhere else. Part of this connectivity is the ease with which WordPress has integrated some of the more powerful social media platforms, extending my reach even further.

Third, WordPress has the greatest potential for growth. The CMS platform is accessible enough for the baby blogger and powerful enough for the likes of The New Yorker, MTV, and BBC America. Whatever your future holds, WordPress is the most powerful and nimble platform available today.

Blogger Mistake #2: They Don’t Define Themselves

No doubt some readers of this post are already crying foul. “If,” you might be saying, “If WordPress has such great features, why does your blog look so dated.” Well spotted. I am overdue for a redesign. However, it only takes 20 seconds with my blog and readers will know what I’m about. The name, the header, the first few lines of text, the “About” page–these things or a quick scan down the recent posts and the reader will know what I’m doing with A Pilgrim in Narnia. A kindred reader may stay and connect, while a reader looking for something else will move on.

So I’m not ignorant of design features. I am phone- and tablet-friendly, but am aiming for computer screen readers. I use a slalom approach for text and pictures (notice how the eye slides down the page between pics) because I am a literary blogger: the pictures highlight, illustrate, and draw the eye to the next paragraph. For it is the paragraphs that matter to me, the words, the ideas. Although I don’t usually write academic posts, generally my readers are literate and well educated (they either have higher degrees or are self-teachers). Almost all of them are voracious readers and many of them are writers, teachers, researchers, or artists. I have defined who I am and love the readers that I have connected with.

While I am still due for a visual upgrade, and I push at the edges of my blog’s defined space, I know who I am and what A Pilgrim in Narnia is about. What about your blog? If I check out your main page will I get it? After looking at the last 20 blogs that have followed A Pilgrim in Narnia, I am reminded that it is a rarer skill than you might think. It doesn’t matter if your subject matter is super narrow or grand and expansive, you only get about 20 seconds with readers to communicate who you are. Define well, visually, in the descriptions, and in your writing.

Blogger Mistake #3: They Don’t Translate

This one is highly controversial. Specialists will roll their eyes when I complain about in-group language. There is a value to working in a specialized community, testing out ideas with one another and inspiring creativity. I work in research teams and know the value of technical language–whether those in the “in group” are economists, comic book collectors, Tolkienists, linguists, astronomers, beat poets, animal rights activists, numismatists in love, Buffy fans, woodworkers, philosophers of technology, angry education reformers, placid Whovians, or international monitors of health standards in aboriginal communities. There is something alluring about the secret handshake.

However, there is nothing more intimidating than to break into than a circle of like-minded folk. At least that’s the case for me when I’m at a party where I don’t know a lot of people. It takes a lot of courage to squeeze in and pick up the thread of a conversation. So every blogger must decide whether his or her blog will be a closed circle–always limited to the very few who know your secret handshake–or will try to keep a place open for the next reader.

I have designed it so that A Pilgrim in Narnia is going to be immediately ignored by 90% of visitors. But for those who love books–especially books of fantasy the Inklings wrote and inspired in others–I want these great readers to stick around. That’s why, for example, I don’t call C.S. Lewis, “Jack,” and I describe his more obscure work so the reader knows where it fits in his overall project. I still remember the joy of discovering that Lewis, Tolkien, and the best Fantasy/SF writers have a largely untapped reservoir of other materials–letters, essays, editorials, failed projects, secretly written poems and diary entries and things they wrote before they were famous. I loved discovering those things, so I share those little treasures with readers.

And, yet, my choice to leave behind groupspeak and specialist language has done nothing to chase away the leading C.S. Lewis and Tolkien scholars. My choice to “translate” my work has opened me up to a much wider readership and has still given space for leaders in my field to offer advice, criticism, or words of encouragement. You can choose to have a tight inner circle of those in the know, or you can share your great knowledge with the world by thinking about the language you use.

Blogger Mistake #4: They Don’t Use Network Features

I find social media age language of followership really creepy. Perhaps I watched too many cult kidnapping films growing up, but I don’t really want to be a follower of digital being.

Yet, that’s the language that has emerged. I have chosen to embrace it, and as soon as it has gone stale I’ll set it aside. But that good instinct to reject “follower” culture has meant that some people have missed some network opportunities. I will give some quick examples:

  • Some bloggers reject the “like” button because, frankly, it seems narcissistic to ask everyone to like what I wrote. However, as a frequent blog reader, when I don’t have time to comment on a blog, and when sharing it doesn’t fit my online profile, a quick click of the “like” button allows me to leave a note of encouragement to the content creator.
  • Not everyone is attracted to Twitter, and the Trumpification of Twitter–along with troll culture–means that it is in danger of disappearing. However, you should use the share button features. This allows readers who have loved what you have made for them to share with their friends (and followers) on Facebook, Pinterest, and Twitter. These social media tools are critical to enhanced network connectivity.
  • So many bloggers miss an opportunity to enhance sharing by not including their Twitter handle in the share feature. Simply go to Sharing Settings and put your Twitter name in the space that says, “Twitter username to include in tweets when people share using the Twitter button.” Even if you only use this to track blog connections, it can allow you to follow up with readers who are otherwise invisible online.
  • Turn on the Reblog feature. There are some bloggers who scoop up and share material as if it is Instagram. Just roll with it and make more online connections.
  • Some don’t open up the comments section, missing critical opportunities to invite readers into a deeper commitment to your blog. I know that there are trolls and spammers, but WordPress has great tools to filter out spam. As for trolls, I approve their crazy comments, leaving them for future readers to enjoy their insipid, mind-numbing commitment to inanity.
  • WordPress has a “follow” feature that links you to the Wordpress Reader. Tags do this too, but how many people are using the WordPress Reader? So many great bloggers miss out on deeply connected readers because they don’t include the email widget. Beyond posts that have gone viral, the email button is the most critical connectivity tool that has led to my success, such as it is.

These are all missed “conversion” opportunities–to use another unfortunate term. You want to convert casual visitors into lifelong readers. These simple tools enhance your connectivity and deepen commitment among your readers. They also give you tools to track blog activity outside of your own site.

Blogger Mistake #5: They Listen to Posts Like This

In the end, your blog must be a sincere representative of who you are in the digital community you live in. The blog “Adventures of a Renegade Stamp Collector” is going to have a different feel than “Numismastatistics: Tools for 21st Century Collectors,” despite the overlap of content and community. You need to create content and visual design features that allow for the most authentic connection between you and your reader. Nothing is worse than the blogger who is trying too hard or who has cluttered the screen with gadgetry, clickbait, or connection points.

Yet a lot of bloggers get caught in these “how to” lists. Sometimes they end up feeling forced into little boxes that make the blogging experience less enjoyable. And doesn’t that go against the whole business that is the play of blogging? This should be fun. Your blog should make you a better writer, hone your technological or design skills, and create a platform for product development or launch. But it should be fun.

Bloggers who forget the joy of the genre do so to their peril.

Good luck, and feel free to add your tips and anti-tips in the comment section below and share on Twitter, Facebook, or Pinterest!

About Brenton Dickieson

“A Pilgrim in Narnia” is a blog project in reading and talking about the work of C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, and the worlds they touched. As a "Faith, Fantasy, and Fiction" blog, we cover topics like children’s literature, apologetics and philosophy, myths and mythology, fantasy, theology, cultural critique, art and writing. This blog includes my thoughts as I read through Lewis and Tolkien and reflect on my own life and culture. In this sense, I am a Pilgrim in Narnia--or Middle Earth, or Fairyland. I am often peeking inside of wardrobes, looking for magic bricks in urban alleys, or rooting through yard sale boxes for old rings. If something here captures your imagination, leave a comment, “like” a post, share with your friends, or sign up to receive Narnian Pilgrim posts in your email box. Brenton Dickieson is a father, husband, friend, university lecturer, and freelance writer from Prince Edward Island, Canada. You can follow him on Twitter, @BrentonDana.
This entry was posted in On Writing, Thoughtful Essays and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

35 Responses to The 5 Most Common Mistakes Bloggers Make

  1. Sara Renée says:

    Great tips, I’m a new blogger and will definitely look into incorporating the things you’ve mentioned, thanks!


  2. traildustfotm says:

    Good pointers, Brenton. Thank you for your advice from experience.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. jamesbradfordpate says:

    Reblogged this on James' Ramblings and commented:
    I don’t follow some of these, which may be part of my problem! Still, these are tips to know.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. cnongpluh says:

    Thank you, that’s very helpful. I’m a new blogger and will bear in mind your advice.


  5. Dacian says:

    Very nice article! Appreciate the great advice, especially as I start out. Thanks!


  6. L.A. Smith says:

    Great! Thanks for the info. I struggle with some of these, including #2, keeping my blog focussed, as well as using social media wisely. I know I don’t do enough on twitter, etc so am trying to be a little better at “liking” and “sharing” other people’s posts as well as not just promoting my posts once on social media. But it’s a slow process, it seems. Onward and upward!


    • Actually, I think your blog has a great focus. I am very clear by what you write–thought your blog subtitle could be more clear. You blog about writing, things writers like to talk about, good books, and the middle ages. A subtitle could probably link all that together for you, perhaps.
      Yes, the more you connect, the more others will connect. But we don’t want to be slaves to connectivity. Social media was made for man, not man for social media.


  7. Ocean Bream says:

    That was funny, you got me in the end! Still, some very sound tips here. I am on the ‘search’ feature of WordPress to discover new and interesting blogs, and it brought me here! Fancy that. I am glad I stumbled here, though, because your writing style is interesting. 🙂


  8. Thanks for your insight. Good tips for me to go back to see if I incorporated them or not.


  9. rlongwort says:

    I am blogging on dreams etc so I will consider what you said and take an other look at my posts. Thanks


  10. saralenja says:

    thank u, your tips are great.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Thank you for sharing these tips with everyone! I found them very informative, and it was also a fun read! May I please ask you a question? What is the “Reblog function” that you mentioned? Thank you very much!


    • Thanks for stopping and commenting. The “reblog” button is just one of the features you can turn on or off in the “Settings” feature of the WordPress dashboard. Go to Settings, then Sharing, and then at the bottom of that list is the “reblog” feature. Make sure it is turned to “on.” It will probably take some time before you find your blogs being reblogged, and it isn’t terribly common.


  12. bemindful26 says:

    Turn on the re-blog feature… not sure what that is. Going to check that out! TY 🙂
    And going to put more pictures in my next post! Love that idea.


    • Thanks for stopping and commenting. The “reblog” button is just one of the features you can turn on or off in the “Settings” feature of the WordPress dashboard. Go to Settings, then Sharing, and then at the bottom of that list is the “reblog” feature. Make sure it is turned to “on.” It will probably take some time before you find your blogs being reblogged, and it isn’t terribly common.


  13. Pingback: The 5 Most Common Mistakes Bloggers Make — A Pilgrim in Narnia | fiscoworld

  14. I started out literally an hour ago! This helped! Thanks!!!


  15. odysseylsv says:

    I just started my blog about 2 to 3 weeks ago, and this is great information. Definitely need to explore the features more in depth. Thanks!


  16. Pingback: Approaching “The Silmarillion” for the First Time | A Pilgrim in Narnia

  17. Pingback: For Anyone Who Is New To Blogging | Site Title

  18. Pingback: The Top 6 New Posts of 2017 | A Pilgrim in Narnia

  19. Pingback: 2017: My Year in Books: The Infographic | A Pilgrim in Narnia

  20. Pingback: The 600,000th Visitor at A Pilgrim In Narnia! | A Pilgrim in Narnia

  21. ChrisC says:

    Mr. Dickieson,

    What advice would you have for someone just starting out in professional blogging when it comes to the handling of image copyrights?

    I’m essentially ready to start posting, however, I’d like to include images from books, movies, even filmclips if necessary. The difficulty is knowing what I can use, or when, and how often. This is why I wondered if you might have any advice for first-timers in this field.

    Is ther anything in particular I should look out for when trying to match word to image?

    If there is something you know that’s helped, and that other bloggers should know, feel free to spread the word. If not, thank you very for listening anyway.




    • Hi Chris,
      I can’t really comment on copyright, except that Google now has a tool to find public utility images. Using Youtube clips is a help, right? Not only do they link well to WordPress, but Youtube has its own sophisticated check system for copyright. Other than that…. I tend to use pictures from other blogs and, especially, book covers.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.